• *tap tap*

    Is this thing on?

    It’s been a while, hasn’t it? I am behind by two birthdays and a vacation. And that’s just scratching the surface. We moved, Matt started a new job, and the school year ended. Life’s been a bit crazy these past few months, but the dust has started to settle and yet I still feel slightly paralyzed when I think about revisiting this blog. And I’ve decided it’s because there’s one story I need to tell before I can start telling all the rest. Even if it’s a hard story to share. So here it goes…

    My “number” has always been four.

    As the years progressed, I realized how lucky I would be to have even one or two. And then Lucy came along, surprising everyone.

    As Lucy grew out of her babyhood, the questions about whether or not Matt and I would try for number four inevitably started. My answer was always the same: we’d both love a fourth but I wasn’t going to go through any medical interventions this time. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn’t, that’s okay.

    Well, that’s easy to say until all of a sudden it doesn’t happen, and you realize you don’t feel so okay about it after all. So after months of being disappointed but pretending not to really be disappointed (if you have ever experienced infertility, you are probably familiar with the amazing mind tricks you manage to play on yourself to try to stay sane), Matt and I decided that if this was really something we wanted – and we both agreed that it was – it was time to go ahead and call my reproductive endocrinologist.

    So last December I did just that and made an appointment to see my old doctor, the one who helped me conceive Claire more than five years ago through IVF.

    The next day I took a home pregnancy test.

    It was positive.

    In that moment, part of me got giddy with excitement and thought about what a great story this would make when I announced my pregnancy in a few months time. But another part of me – the part that has been down this road far too many times before – knew there was a good chance I would never get to make that announcement.

    It was that same part of me that decided to keep that appointment at the fertility clinic just in case, and the same part that responded very matter-of-factly a few weeks later when I got the call telling me what I already knew: that my pregnancy hormone levels were dropping and I was most likely having a miscarriage.

    In January I went to that appointment and made a plan with my doctor. Shortly afterward, there was another positive pregnancy test, and another small seed of hope that ended in disappointment.

    And so in February I strapped myself in and started my IVF cycle, and all the daily injections and constant 6:45am doctor’s visits that went along with it. The numbers from that cycle went like this:

    22 eggs retrieved. 11 mature. 2 fertilized normally. 0 survived.

    I was so confident that things would work out for me just like they did with Claire that this result was a huge blow to me. It was in that moment that I realized for the first time that the picture I’d always imagined of my family really might never become a reality.

    At this point I was emotionally and physically exhausted. I would have loved to just forget the whole thing and move on with life. But I didn’t ever want to find myself at some point down the road regretting that I didn’t try hard enough. And so I decided to do one more cycle, which I started in late April. To quote my favorite nurse Cathie, things “looked beautiful” this time around. The numbers from cycle #2 went like this:

    20 eggs retrieved. 13 mature. 10 fertilized.

    I’m not going to lie. Hopes were extremely high this time around. So when my doctor called on day 6 to report how many embryos we would be able to freeze and test via CCS (because of my miscarriage history), my heart sank when he told me there was only 1 that was still hanging on, and the quality of that one embryo was so poor that it was most likely not viable and would not survive the freeze process.

    And just like that, the door officially swung shut behind me. There would be no number four for us.

    Could I have tried again? Maybe. But two times was the line I had drawn in the sand. The emotional toll of IVF can’t be underestimated (even though I liked to shrug it off as no big deal), and there was no doubt that my girls got the short end of the stick during those months as a result. At some point I knew it was time to re-focus on them.

    To be honest, once I knew the outcome of the second IVF cycle I felt like a weight had been lifted. Just to have an answer one way or another was such a relief. I was really positive about the whole thing until nurse Cathie called and left me a message a few days later. On it I heard this tough, no-nonsense woman holding back tears and telling me how disappointed she was for me.

    And that’s when I realized it was okay to be sad.

    I think this whole time I’ve felt a little silly. I’ve thought a lot about how people out there – especially women struggling to have just one child (aka my 2003 self) – would probably think I am ridiculous not to be satisfied with the three incredible and dynamic children I already have. And it’s true that words really can’t do justice to express how grateful I am for their presence in my life. They are more than I could have ever imagined. But we all have different visions for our lives, and I had to give myself permission to mourn the loss of this particular dream.

    Ironically, for somebody who is really bad at goodbyes, I think the hardest part for me is to think that I missed out on properly saying goodbye to all my lasts: last birth experience, last middle of the night feedings, last first steps. And the reminder that those lasts have already come and gone keep surprising me like a punch in the gut, like when I’m unpacking boxes and suddenly come across old baby gear I’ve been carefully saving that I suddenly realize I have no use for anymore.

    I can’t lie and say that it’s not hard for me when Ella tells me how much she wants another baby in our house. If only she understood how desperately I tried to give that to her. I also can’t tell you that the empty sixth chair at our dining room table never catches my eye or puts a pit in my stomach.

    But I can tell you that my love and gratitude for my girls has been magnified by this experience, and bit by bit I’m allowing a new vision for our family to take hold.

    Matt’s lucky number has always been three.

    And I’m beginning to see that maybe that’s been my number all along too.


  • 2013 has been a quiet year for my camera so far. I have taken significantly fewer everyday photos this year than in years past, probably because I’ve been too preoccupied with all the major changes going on in our lives to remember to pick up the camera on a regular basis. It’s not something I’ve stressed out about, but I am really glad that back in February I decided to follow along with Ali Edwards’ Day in the Life project. I took more photos during that day than I had during the entire month.

    In addition to taking photos I also kept a detailed log of our activities throughout the day. Hopefully someday soon I’ll actually compile everything into a template and print it out. Here are a few photos from a day in our life on February 28th (and yes, I was also inspired by Ali when I labeled these photos):

    Ali is doing a Day in the Life once a month for this entire year. If you want to give it a try, you can join in next Tuesday, April 30th. I’ll probably participate at least one or two more times later on in the year.

  • For a girl who has only ever wanted to celebrate her birthday at home with family, it seemed fitting that Claire should be the last person to celebrate a birthday in our old house just one week before we moved.

    On her actual birthday, a Wednesday, she woke up and asked if the birds and butterflies were here now since it was also the first day of spring. Sadly, there was still snow on the ground. I took her out on a lunch date to Panera Bread (her request) and then we got our nails done together just like last year. I asked her if she wanted to invite a couple of friends from school to come with us, but she just wanted it to be me and her. “Maybe for my six-year-old birthday,” she said. That evening she opened up her presents: a ballet bag, a heart locket with a picture of Mom and Dad inside, and a two new fairy books. It was exactly what she had asked for.

    On Saturday we had our family celebration. Even though life was a bit crazy at the time, I tried to make it special
    for her. But I didn’t order the edible butterflies for her cake in time, so the mailman ended up delivering them just a couple of hours after we ate the cake. But who really cares about edible butterflies anyway when you have an entire edible cake to eat?

    I made a variation on last year’s rainbow cake. This year’s version was four layers in varying shades of pink.

    After cake we headed into New York City to have afternoon tea at American Girl Place. It was ridiculously overpriced, even by New York standards, which led Matt to declare that this was “truly a once in a lifetime experience.” (It wouldn’t have been so bad except for the fact that I think we were hungrier when we left than we were when we arrived, if that’s possible.) The highlight for Claire was getting her new doll Caroline. I was rooting for her to choose my personal favorite Kit (I guess Lucy is my last hope on that front), but Claire fell in love with that curly blonde hair. The next day she declared: “I am really loving Caroline because she has such beautiful hair.” She’s slept with Caroline next to her every night since.

    She’s in for exciting things this year. She’s learning how to read, kindergarten starts in the fall, and she’s about to lose her first tooth. It’s definitely good to be five.

    Here is this year’s birthday interview. It’s really interesting to compare her answers to the ones she gave last year and see which ones stayed the same (she still wants to be a mommy when she grows up) and which ones changed (American Girls have replaced Hello Kitty for favorite toy):

    My favorite fruit is: strawberries.
    My favorite TV show is: Full House (the girls are hooked on re-runs).
    My favorite thing to eat for lunch is: a peanut butter and jelly sandwich.
    My favorite outfit is: all of Ella’s old dresses (the barely worn ones that I just pulled out of storage).
    My favorite drink is: soda (said with a sly grin because she very rarely gets soda). Alternate answer: lemonade.
    The toy I love to play with most is: my American Girl dolls.
    Something that makes me scared is: loud noises.
    My favorite animal is: a pig… no, an elephant!
    My best subject in school is: art.
    The thing I do the most awesomely is: numbers.
    If I could go anywhere in the world, I’d go to: Florida beach.
    My favorite color is: pink.
    My favorite thing to do on the weekend is: read my fairy books.
    The snack I could live on is: goldfish.
    My best friend is: Hope and Rian.
    If I had one wish it would be: to stay with my family all the days.
    When I grow up, I’m going to become a: mommy.

  • “I think I made the wrong choice.”

    That’s what Ella said as she sobbed last Saturday night after a long day of packing up boxes and watching the movers come and empty out this little old house that has watched our family grow for the past six years. Even with all my planning and organization (including a detailed packing log), I
    was not prepared for how exhausting and emotional this whole moving process
    would be.

    Ella has been dying for her own room, and we promised her that she could have one once we moved. As the moving date got closer, I tried to convince her to wait until the second move into our new house to make the switch, but she was adamant that she was ready now.

    And then on that first night in the rental as I was in Claire and Lucy’s new room trying to make up their beds, Ella came in, looked at me for a moment, and burst into tears. These weren’t your regular “I scraped my knee” tears or “my sister got a bigger cookie than me” tears, but real, gut-wrenching tears. Having her own room lost its appeal after she was confronted with the reality of sleeping in a dark room by herself without her constant companion of the last five years.

    I cried right along with her that night. It may seem trivial in the grand scheme of things, but this was probably the first time in her almost eight years on earth that she’s had to face something really hard, scary, and seemingly overwhelming for her. If I hadn’t felt like I was literally going to collapse from exhaustion in that moment, I would have moved her bed back in with Claire’s by myself that very night. Instead I did my best to calm her down and told her we’d figure it out the next day. She later told me that she stayed awake staring at the door with tears rolling down her face all night long. It broke my heart.

    After that I was sure that she would decide to move back in with Claire, at least for the next couple of months until the next move. So the next evening when she told me that although she would miss Claire (“she really was a good roommate”), she was no longer afraid and still wanted her own room, I was the one who ended up crying. It just felt like too much change all at once, and I was worried that they would start to lose their close relationship. So all week long Ella’s been writing me notes to try to make me feel better about things, filled with memories of sharing a room with Claire like “falling on your pillow,” a game they apparently liked to play that involved standing at the foot of their beds and falling face first onto their pillows.

    The day after our move was Easter. Despite being completely unprepared (at least the Easter Bunny still managed to find us), I was able to scrounge up some Easter-ish outfits for the girls – two out of three wore hand me down outfits that I pulled out of a bin minutes before we walked out the door – and we headed to our old house to say our final goodbyes and have an Easter egg hunt in the backyard.



    Afterward, Matt loaded the girls into the car and I stood by myself in the kitchen, staring for the last time into the empty living room with tears rolling down my face this time.

    I didn’t expect to be so emotional over the whole thing, but it felt a little bit like the end of an era. I just couldn’t stop thinking about two of my babies coming home to this house from the hospital, Christmas mornings, the girls playing in the backyard, hearing their footsteps on the squeaky stairs as they came downstairs to ask for just one more thing before falling asleep, Lucy yelling good night to her sisters from across the hall, first day of school pictures in front of the white fence, the girls sitting on the kitchen counter while I made dinner, and the list goes on and on.

    In that moment I really just wanted to call the whole thing off and forget about this selling our house business. But on Monday the papers were signed and we handed off the keys to a family with two boys who will hopefully make many more happy memories there.

    Just as the morning brought a fresh perspective to Ella, a few days of distance (and some sleep) has helped my own emotions to subside. I do know that this was the right decision for us and that it was time to move on. And I’m looking forward to finally moving into our new house.

    We have settled into life in our rental house. None of us can quite bring ourselves to call it home; even Lucy calls it simply “the rental.” I have to drive by our old house at least once a day on my way to drop off Claire at school, and my heart drops a little bit each time we pass by. The good news is that Lucy is thrilled to be sharing a room with Claire. That first night she was so excited she screamed and started hugging all the furniture in the room. Claire seems content with both living arrangements. “I just want to share a room with all my sisters,” she tells me.

    The other night however, things in Claire and Lucy’s new shared room got a little too rowdy, so I pulled Claire out and told her to go into Ella’s room until Lucy fell asleep. A few minutes later I peeked in and saw Ella reading a book to Claire, the two of them snuggled up together on Ella’s bed, and for a moment all was right with the world again.

    There may be a lot of change afoot in our lives right now, but at least I can count on some things remain the same.

  • I have received a few comments about my absence in this space over the past couple of months. The truth is, if you look back over the history of this blog, I tend to get much quieter in the winter.

    This marked my 7th New England winter, and over the years I’ve actually come to really appreciate and enjoy the quiet that January and February brings
    after a whirlwind holiday season. The only problem with this winter is that I haven’t really been able to hibernate the cold months away like I normally do (although I did spend a good portion of February watching all four seasons of Parenthood).

    First of all, we put our house back on the market (you may remember that we tried to sell our house two years ago without success) at the end of January and it sold in one day. This was great news, but it has meant that we’ve been scrambling to find a short-term rental to move into while also searching for a new home to buy (thankfully we just signed contracts for a place we’re really excited about last week). And on top of that, we’ve been juggling a couple of other pretty major things that have taken up a lot of our attention as well. It’s mostly all good, but it’s meant that I’ve been a bit distracted, to say the least.

    But spring is officially here now, and for the first time in a long time, I finally feel ready to come and revisit this old blog of mine. Things are about to get pretty crazy for a while (moving day is just a little over a week away), but hopefully I’ll be here a little more often from here on out.

  • Finally… we are up to the last week of 2012! Let’s start with Christmas Eve.

    Of course there was the traditional Christmas Eve program in New Jersey. With Matt’s sister and her family joining the East Coast ranks this year, there were lots of extra performers.

    Ella played her violin and despite our wild applause, burst into tears afterwards because she forgot the ending. That sweet kid just breaks my heart sometimes. She is truly becoming quite a lovely violinist and I assured her that she should be proud of herself.

    Claire, on the other hand, refused to perform her “violin demonstration” at all. Stinker. And since she’s only two, Lucy got a pass to just sit, look cute, and fawn all over her baby cousin Lily.

    Matt and I truly stepped up our acts this year. I wrote (with Matt’s help) and recited my own version of “The Night Before Christmas.” Usually Matt just sings “Jingle Bells” with the girls, but this year he performed a vocal solo of “Santa Claus is Coming to Town” using a different accent for each verse. It was somewhat politically incorrect and completely hysterical. Lucy pulls up the video on my iPhone every chance she gets and it brings me to tears pretty much every time I watch it.

    After the program and our second annual Christmas Eve BBQ dinner (shipped straight from Texas), it was home to leave milk and cookies for Santa and go to bed.


    Christmas Day is one of the few times where I take hardly any photos. This is one of the only pictures I have from the day of Lucy wearing the fairy costume that was a gift from my mom (she put it on immediately upon opening it). It was a lovely, happy holiday though, despite the lack of photographic evidence. Ella’s favorite gifts were her Nintendo DS and LEGO Creator set. Claire loved her jewelry box and fairy book. And Lucy was mostly just thrilled to rip open presents regardless of what was inside. And honestly, my kids loved staying in their pajamas all day more than anything else. It’s one of the things they look forward to most about Christmas!

    The day after Christmas, we left Lucy with a sitter and headed into the city to see Annie on Broadway.

    And to end the year, we finally got a little bit of snow. It wasn’t much, but it was enough to go sledding in the backyard and make snowballs with our new snowball maker (which was surprisingly effective!). I think this was the first time that Lucy actually enjoyed the snow. She loved screaming at the top of her lungs every time she went sledding down the hill with Matt.

  • This week we had our annual gingerbread house making day. I made the big house above, and the girls each worked on their own individual little houses:

    The finished products:

    This week I also got to go into Ella’s classroom and help out with the class holiday party. Somehow I have managed to be in charge of doing a holiday craft in Ella’s class every single year since kindergarten. In September, parents usually sign up to help out with celebrations throughout the year, and I always tell the teacher that I will fill in any open slots. It appears that holiday craft volunteers are hard to come by in our neck of the woods.

    I actually love being in the classroom, but trying to come up with a holiday craft is usually a bit stressful for me. This year my process went something like this: 1) Spend hours searching for ideas on Pinterest, 2) Choose a really adorable but overly elaborate project for a classroom full of 23 second graders, 3) Go to Michael’s to buy supplies and become completely overwhelmed, and 4) Decide to take the easy way out and end up buying boxes of pre-made gingerbread men for the kids to decorate instead. When it was all said and done, the cookie decorating was a huge hit and I was amazed at how creative the kids were.

    I love that Ella wore a Santa hat to school for the entire week leading up to the holiday break.

    I got to observe Claire in ballet class performing various dances from the Nutcracker:

    And we finally went to see Santa:

    In a repeat performance from last year, Lucy wanted nothing to do with Santa, so in order to get a picture with all three girls Matt had to sit on Santa’s lap too:

    Sharing their wish lists with Santa:

    Claire told Santa that she didn’t know what she wanted for Christmas. Santa replied that he couldn’t fit “I don’t know” in his bag, but asked if it would be okay to surprise her with something special. She agreed that it was a good plan.

  • It was a mostly quiet December week around here, at least until The Elf Emergency of 2012 occurred.

    On the day Buddy created this M&M message for the girls (by the way, you should know that Buddy steals all his ideas from other elves posting on Facebook and Pinterest), Lucy touched him. Anybody who is familiar with Elf on the Shelf lore knows that an elf loses its magic if touched. As soon as it happened, Ella burst into tears. I suggested writing a letter to Santa to explain the situation and she got right to work. Since Buddy would not be able to fly back to the North Pole that night to report to Santa, she made sure to include her own report on “Thursday’s attitude.” Note that the only person she gave a smiley face to was herself. In order to speed the process along, I also sent Santa an e-mail and he had some “Magic Elf Dust” (thank you Google) waiting for us in our mailbox the next day, so all was right in the world again.

    On Saturday, Ella headed into New York with her good friend Will and his family to see the Christmas Spectacular at Radio City, so I promised Claire and Lucy we would do something fun at home. Baking cookies seemed to fit the bill. Ella even got home in time to decorate a few herself.

    Matt strings lights on our second tree of the season.

    Saturday was also the day we brought home Christmas tree #2. A couple of days after we chopped down our first tree, we somehow forgot to water it for 48 hours and it never really recovered from the neglect. It probably would have hobbled along until Christmas, but Matt determined that we should just cut our losses and get another one before things got any worse. So we undecorated tree #1 and hauled it outside, then headed down to a local nursery to pick out a replacement. When Ella got home from the Christmas Spectacular she immediately declared that she hated the new tree, and although my sentiments weren’t quite as strong, I have to admit that I really missed the original too.

  • Claire @ Lincoln Center.

    The director of Claire’s ballet studio arranged an outing to see a performance of The Nutcracker by the New York City Ballet, so I turned it into a mother/daughter outing.

    Claire on the subway platform.

    We rode the train into the city and then took the subway uptown. By the way, when you’re patting yourself on the back for how well you know your way around New York, nothing humbles you like getting on the express train when you actually needed the local.

    Our first stop was brunch at The Smith. Claire got a buttermilk waffle and ate the entire thing, saving the whipped cream for last.

    Then it was time for the show. Afterward, Claire and I both gave it two thumbs up.

    Claire on the train ride home, wearing her Nutcracker souvenir.

    I let Claire pick out one souvenir each for herself and for both of her sisters. She chose a wooden nutcracker for Ella, and this tiara for herself and Lucy (even though I tried to direct her to an adorable mini snow globe instead). You don’t want to know how much I paid for that tiara, but I tried to tell myself that it was all part of the experience. It wouldn’t have felt like a trip into New York City if I didn’t grossly overpay for something.

    Back at home this week, I managed to get the tree decorated.

    Our elf Buddy showed up, albeit a bit later than usual (Ella complained that several of her friends at school had elves who arrived last week). Buddy left a note explaining that he had been caught in “elf traffic,” which seemed like a plausible excuse to the girls. All week he was up to typical elf antics such as getting into a tin of cookies and toilet-papering our tree.

    I spotted this sweet bookmark on Ella’s nightstand.


    Lucy was feeling a bit under the weather this week, and then Matt came down with a horrible version of the stomach flu that left him knocked out for several days. Once he finally felt like he might be able to stomach something, he sent me the following grocery store requests via e-mail:

    From: Matthew Woodbury

    To: Jennifer Woodbury


    Date: Fri, Dec 7, 2012 at 3:25pm


    Subject: Wish List

    Don’t laugh.

    1) Chicken in a Biskit

    2) Gatorade (yellow or orange)


    3) Sour Patch Kid popsicles


    4) Ginger ale


    5) Sour cream and onion Pringles

    I only laughed a little… I guess there’s nothing like sour cream and onion Pringles to settle an upset stomach. 🙂

  • Heading off to school. Every day Lucy insists on taking a backpack with her in the morning just like the big girls. Inside the backpack is a lunch box. She follows me around the kitchen in the morning filling it up with every snack food item imaginable.

    The Christmas cards arrived.

    The Santa letters have been written. This is Ella’s. All Claire wants for Christmas is rosin (for her violin), a “fairy book” (even though she can’t read them, she is obsessed with these somewhat insufferable Rainbow Magic books), and a charm bracelet, so Santa is going to have to be a bit creative.

    On Saturday, we went with the Shontzes on our 2nd annual Christmas tree hunt.

    It was absolutely freezing outside (a bit different than last year), and I couldn’t feel my toes by the end, but we found our tree! Never mind that we managed to kill it within two weeks of getting it home by forgetting to water it, but I suppose that’s a story for another blog post.


    Ella helps carry the tree to the car.