You have probably heard this story before. Way back when, I started out as a paper scrapbooker. Then when Ella was born in 2005, I discovered digital scrapbooking and swore I would never touch paper again. And then life got too busy and I stopped scrapbooking altogether.

Last year, I quietly tiptoed back into the scrapbooking world using Project Life. There was no digital option available at the time so I used the physical product and even went so far as to use my own handwriting (something I had never done before even in my paper days).

This year I thought I might type my journaling cards, but other than that I didn’t expect much else to change when it came to Project Life. But then I decided to try the new digital products and was reminded of all the things I loved about digital scrapbooking.

Thus began my minor identity crisis. Was I a paper or a digital girl at heart? I spent the first few weeks of the year creating both digital and physical pages trying to figure things out and settle on one or the other. But the answer to my question, I realized, was that I am both. And so I decided to create my pages both digitally and with the paper product in 2012. This may seem like a lot of extra time and duplicate work, but surprisingly it really isn’t. By the time I get the digital version for the week done, the majority of the work for the physical pages is already done. I mostly just have to print and slide everything into the page protectors. Project Life is all about simplicity for me, so I would never attempt this if I thought it was taking too much extra time.

I have been designing my pages in Photoshop using the Design A page template and the Clementine kit. I love doing it this way first because it allows me to see exactly which photos I need to print and what sizes I need them to be. Here is my Week 1 digital spread (click the photo to view larger):

2012Week1f

Then I send my photos off to be printed and print out my journaling cards on my home printer and that digital spread turns into these physical pages:

2012Week1e

As another example, here is the digital version of Week 2:

2012Week2f

And the physical version of the same week:

2012Week2e

My vision is to have the physical album be our family book, which I will still be able to fill with the “extras” of life (cards, school work, etc.), and then use the digital pages to create smaller photo books for each of my girls at the end of the year.

I am not sharing this with you because I think this is the best way to do things. In fact, I don’t expect this approach to work for most people. Realistically, I know that the majority of you will prefer one method over another. The last thing I want to do is make things seem more complicated since that goes against the whole spirit of Project Life in the first place. What I am hoping is that seeing Project Life used in different ways gives you a good sense of the options available and hopefully helps you figure out the best way to document your own story.

Products used:


Posted in

18 responses to “My Project Life Identity Crisis”

  1. Debbie Avatar
    Debbie

    Hi Jennifer! I love this idea. I have been struggling with the fact that I have two little girls and one book. The question I have for you is, why did you choose to use the digital version in photoshop instead of going to shutterfly? Also, I noticed an Ali Edwards brush, can you use other products in the digital version?
    Thanks,
    Debbie

  2. Anja Avatar
    Anja

    Jennifer, i´m so, so happy about this post! Cause i had exactly the same crisis and thoughts, since the release of the digital version of PL. I downloaded everything, loved to scrap digitally again and then I didn´t know what to choose for my PL album… This crisis even brought me so far, that i stopped working on my PL for 2012 – wich of course brings me to the next crisis! 😉 But that´s another story… I really didn´t know what to do. And yes, i also thought about doing both (cause i also really love to add extras to the albums and i would love to have extra albums for my girl), but i thought this was too crazy!! BUT Jennifer, now that you´re doing this, i think i´ll give it a try. 🙂 I really love, love, love this! Thanks for pushing me into the right direction. I definitly needed this! 🙂
    Greetings from far away 😉 (Germany)

  3. MaryAnn P Avatar

    I absolutely love it!!! What a perfect idea!!! Totally going to implement this somehow….I love the thought of being able to have the digital versions as well as the paper versions….I love how clean and beautiful your pages look….simply gorgeous!!!

  4. Leisel Avatar
    Leisel

    Thanks for sharing this idea! I too wanted to somehow pass it on to my kids without all the extra work. I love your design style and practicality!

  5. Erica Avatar

    You are a girl after my own heart…I have the same process (though I don’t use the “official” PL elements.)

  6. Katy Avatar

    I came over from Becky’s blog – first, I have to say that I’m very much drawn to your pages because you have a very simple, clean style which I LOVE. I’ve actually been meaning to do this (do a digital and paper version), but I was just going to do it to see if I want to make the transition to digital – if I missed putting the extra ‘stuff’ in, I’d know that paper was the way to go for me (like last year). But reading this I realize that if I do digital as well, I can print it out for the kids or whatnot. How silly that I didn’t think of that!:)
    Plus, if I get behind in the paper version or start preferring the digial, I at least have it all saved somewhere. AND I can be recording everything digitally and just print it all out/rewrite on cards once a month or so. Thanks for the ideas!
    One more question: it appears that you do more of a ‘week in review’ (is that correct?) – how is that working for you? I usually do picture-a-day, but for the days I miss I want to look it at as more of weekly layout idea, which I’m assuming means that if I miss taking pictures a few days out of the week, I can just use more than picture from a single day (as it appears on your above). Again, such a simple thing, but I’m trying to reason through it in my mind.
    Thanks for the great inspiration!

  7. shelby Avatar

    this is such an awesomely amazing idea! I am a paper girl…heart and soul, but decided I would do the digital version this year, just so that I would stick with it because I havent had much luck staying with the project the last few years.
    Question…where do you have your pages printed??

  8. Laura Avatar
    Laura

    Fantastic idea. Copying. What I’m wondering…is do you use the paper journal cards that come with the kit? I can’t line up the lines with the text on mine on the ones that come with the kit and I see yours are lined up so beautifully…thinking they must be all digital, then printed? P.S. Thanks for the inspiration. I am already 3 weeks behind…and felt as though perhaps I was into a project and already quitting. Going to keep at it.

  9. Anja Avatar
    Anja

    Me again. 🙂 Can you tell me wich font(s) you are using for your journaling cards? And do you print them on cardstock or photopaper? And i hope you don’t mind that i have another question: What do you plan to do on a special occasion like a b-day or a vacation when you want to use extra page protectors for more photos in your physical album? Will you just be ok with maybe one picture in the digital layout for occasions like this? Or like the birthday interview you did with Ella. Do you have an idea how to include extra things like that into the digital version or will you just leave that out?
    Thank you so much for your time! You are truly such a huge inspiration to me! Thanks!!! ❤

  10. Sheri Avatar

    Jennifer, I LOVE that you are doing digital versions! When I first started following your blog you were on Heather Ann’s design team and I have always loved your style! Way to go! I love this idea! I have often thought that I am missing out on keeping the “paper stuff” that goes with life, but I have another way I am going to tackle that, at least I hope it works out the way I have intended in my head right now! LOL. Good for you to have little books for your girls, they will LOVE them!! As always, great photos and stories!!

  11. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Good gosh that’s brilliant. I love the way you design in Photoshop first – so clever! I think I might give that a go myself. Thank you for sharing, and for the inspiration! Have a great day! 🙂

  12. Janelle Avatar

    You are my PL hero,lol. I love this idea, great to have the 3D for family stuff, perf to pass on the digi set to the kids. Brilliant.
    I am really commenting to tell you that I have been following your blog for 3 years and it always surprises me how similar our tastes our (kids’ clothes, decor, etc.) but this was a new one… WE do OUr TJ’s cinnamon rolls on Sunday morning. Haha, too weird. Must be kindred spirits, I guess.
    Keep up the good work.

  13. libbywilko Avatar
    libbywilko

    Love this idea Jennifer! Thank you so much for sharing it, I’m loving the digi layouts the ct are making… But I was wondering how to include all the memorabilia I am amassing lol and you have given me a great solution..do both ! Totally like that you design it digitally then do it with the plastics 🙂

  14. Anja Avatar
    Anja

    Jennifer, i just read my post again and with “digital version” i mean the photobooks you are doing for your girls. I hope you understand what i mean. 🙂 Sorry, my english isn’t the best… I tried to explain it somehow. 🙂 Thanks

  15. Emily Avatar
    Emily

    I thought I posted a comment yesterday but don’t see it today. I was wondering how you print on your journaling cards? Or do you print them yourself from your digital kit?

  16. Mindy Avatar
    Mindy

    oh!!! i love this! i am having a hard time figuring out which photos to print & to put where and never thought of doing it this way. now i can sit with my laptop & pan it out then print. LOVE!!! thank you so much for the inspiration!

  17. Amy Avatar
    Amy

    I did it with paper last year & started that way again this year. But… I’ve officially switched to digi myself. I’m planning to print them in a Blurb book at the end. I do print them on 8×11 during the process though so I can enjoy – but I’ll have to wait for the final product.
    Great pages too!

  18. Shayne Avatar
    Shayne

    Silly question, I absolutely love this idea, as I was struggling on which to choose. Want the book, but also feel like I want copies for my children. Does this mean however that you must doubly invest in both the physical paper version and the digital version?

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Jennifer Woodbury

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading