*tap tap*

Is this thing on?

It’s been a while, hasn’t it? I am behind by two birthdays and a vacation. And that’s just scratching the surface. We moved, Matt started a new job, and the school year ended. Life’s been a bit crazy these past few months, but the dust has started to settle and yet I still feel slightly paralyzed when I think about revisiting this blog. And I’ve decided it’s because there’s one story I need to tell before I can start telling all the rest. Even if it’s a hard story to share. So here it goes…

My “number” has always been four.

As the years progressed, I realized how lucky I would be to have even one or two. And then Lucy came along, surprising everyone.

As Lucy grew out of her babyhood, the questions about whether or not Matt and I would try for number four inevitably started. My answer was always the same: we’d both love a fourth but I wasn’t going to go through any medical interventions this time. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn’t, that’s okay.

Well, that’s easy to say until all of a sudden it doesn’t happen, and you realize you don’t feel so okay about it after all. So after months of being disappointed but pretending not to really be disappointed (if you have ever experienced infertility, you are probably familiar with the amazing mind tricks you manage to play on yourself to try to stay sane), Matt and I decided that if this was really something we wanted – and we both agreed that it was – it was time to go ahead and call my reproductive endocrinologist.

So last December I did just that and made an appointment to see my old doctor, the one who helped me conceive Claire more than five years ago through IVF.

The next day I took a home pregnancy test.

It was positive.

In that moment, part of me got giddy with excitement and thought about what a great story this would make when I announced my pregnancy in a few months time. But another part of me – the part that has been down this road far too many times before – knew there was a good chance I would never get to make that announcement.

It was that same part of me that decided to keep that appointment at the fertility clinic just in case, and the same part that responded very matter-of-factly a few weeks later when I got the call telling me what I already knew: that my pregnancy hormone levels were dropping and I was most likely having a miscarriage.

In January I went to that appointment and made a plan with my doctor. Shortly afterward, there was another positive pregnancy test, and another small seed of hope that ended in disappointment.

And so in February I strapped myself in and started my IVF cycle, and all the daily injections and constant 6:45am doctor’s visits that went along with it. The numbers from that cycle went like this:

22 eggs retrieved. 11 mature. 2 fertilized normally. 0 survived.

I was so confident that things would work out for me just like they did with Claire that this result was a huge blow to me. It was in that moment that I realized for the first time that the picture I’d always imagined of my family really might never become a reality.

At this point I was emotionally and physically exhausted. I would have loved to just forget the whole thing and move on with life. But I didn’t ever want to find myself at some point down the road regretting that I didn’t try hard enough. And so I decided to do one more cycle, which I started in late April. To quote my favorite nurse Cathie, things “looked beautiful” this time around. The numbers from cycle #2 went like this:

20 eggs retrieved. 13 mature. 10 fertilized.

I’m not going to lie. Hopes were extremely high this time around. So when my doctor called on day 6 to report how many embryos we would be able to freeze and test via CCS (because of my miscarriage history), my heart sank when he told me there was only 1 that was still hanging on, and the quality of that one embryo was so poor that it was most likely not viable and would not survive the freeze process.

And just like that, the door officially swung shut behind me. There would be no number four for us.

Could I have tried again? Maybe. But two times was the line I had drawn in the sand. The emotional toll of IVF can’t be underestimated (even though I liked to shrug it off as no big deal), and there was no doubt that my girls got the short end of the stick during those months as a result. At some point I knew it was time to re-focus on them.

To be honest, once I knew the outcome of the second IVF cycle I felt like a weight had been lifted. Just to have an answer one way or another was such a relief. I was really positive about the whole thing until nurse Cathie called and left me a message a few days later. On it I heard this tough, no-nonsense woman holding back tears and telling me how disappointed she was for me.

And that’s when I realized it was okay to be sad.

I think this whole time I’ve felt a little silly. I’ve thought a lot about how people out there – especially women struggling to have just one child (aka my 2003 self) – would probably think I am ridiculous not to be satisfied with the three incredible and dynamic children I already have. And it’s true that words really can’t do justice to express how grateful I am for their presence in my life. They are more than I could have ever imagined. But we all have different visions for our lives, and I had to give myself permission to mourn the loss of this particular dream.

Ironically, for somebody who is really bad at goodbyes, I think the hardest part for me is to think that I missed out on properly saying goodbye to all my lasts: last birth experience, last middle of the night feedings, last first steps. And the reminder that those lasts have already come and gone keep surprising me like a punch in the gut, like when I’m unpacking boxes and suddenly come across old baby gear I’ve been carefully saving that I suddenly realize I have no use for anymore.

I can’t lie and say that it’s not hard for me when Ella tells me how much she wants another baby in our house. If only she understood how desperately I tried to give that to her. I also can’t tell you that the empty sixth chair at our dining room table never catches my eye or puts a pit in my stomach.

But I can tell you that my love and gratitude for my girls has been magnified by this experience, and bit by bit I’m allowing a new vision for our family to take hold.

Matt’s lucky number has always been three.

And I’m beginning to see that maybe that’s been my number all along too.


Posted in

31 responses to “Numbers”

  1. Courtney Avatar
    Courtney

    Those are three very lucky (and spunky) girls!
    Infertility sucks. I remember feeling guilty and silly at the level of grief I felt when I miscarried in between the girls and Chase since I already had so many kids but that doesn’t mean that my sadness was not legitimate.
    I hope you can find joy and peace in your sweet family.

  2. Stephanie R Avatar

    (Who knows if you remember me, but I’ve kept you on my RSS feed all these years. And I know that this is partly why.)
    My heart just sank for you and your family. You (and Nurse Cathie) are right. It is ok to grieve the loss of a dream. It’s more than ok. Infertility stinks. It is the meanest SOB I’ve ever met and I wish I could throat punch it for you and me and so many (too many) other women and families.
    I know there is nothing to be said so just know that I’ll be thinking of you and praying that God will continue to comfort and draw you near to Him.

  3. June K Avatar
    June K

    Thank you for sharing what you have been going through. Your three girls are so adorable and I can understand how they bring you and Matt so much joy. Big hugs to you.

  4. Melissa Avatar

    I’ve been a reader for a couple of years now. I’ve enjoyed your pictures and stories. You have a beautiful family. That grieving you are going thru/went thru is something I had experienced as well when my hopes for a particular dream came up short. I have constant reminders each day about it, but I do look at what I have and just embrace all that goodness. You have SO much good. Be kind to yourself, you have three amazing miracles that make you smile each and every day. =)

  5. mandy Avatar
    mandy

    Oh man, I already knew this story and yet I kept hoping the ending would be different. So sorry that you had to go through all of that.
    Enjoy those girls and keep blogging.

  6. Melissa Avatar

    I know the pain of failed IVF cycles and how hard they can be. Our infertility journey resulted in two adoptions from South Korea, but the two sweet kiddos I do have doesn’t take away the pain of the losing a dream.

  7. Bridget =) Avatar

    big gentle hugs.
    I am glad to see you back!!!! XO

  8. Krista Avatar

    Oh! I so feel for you!!! I’m so sorry. I know that empty feeling of “one more”. Last year, right before we moved to CO we did a frozen embryo transfer. Just one this time (the thought of another set of twins kind of freaked me out) and I kick myself for not using both… But that obviously didn’t work and we have one more frozen embryo hanging out in Charlotte. Question of timing and money have prevented us from the last transfer, but hopefully soon. Recently, in June (and amidst a crazy trip and other very taxing medical emergencies) I found out I was pregnant. Very shocked! You probably know the feeling, but I wasn’t allowing myself to “feel” it or get excited to protect my heart… And unfortunately, last weekend I miscarried. I’m trying to put it all together and understand why I even got pregnant in the first place… but those are never good questions to ponder on too much… Thanks for sharing your story! I’m so, so thankful for my two crazy boys and the little miracles that they are, but I still feel a little empty, like there should be one more. I’ve loved reading your blog over the years, you have inspired me in many ways in my life. I wish you all the best as you move forward with your amazing family!

  9. Lizzie Avatar

    Thank you for sharing this! You beautifully expressed your thoughts. I’m sorry that you’ve had to go through all this. This is actually the third post I’ve read this week on the subject, & my heart aches about it.
    Your family is gorgeous & I have always admired your mothering! Would love to get together soon…
    xoxo.

  10. ellen patton Avatar

    Thanks for sharing your story.

  11. LeAnne B Avatar

    Hugs to you. 🙂 Love reading your blog, thanks for sharing your story. Your story tugs at my heart and reminds me to cherish all those little moments while my littles are still little.

  12. Janene Avatar
    Janene

    Thanks for sharing, it is truly hard to say good bye to the vision we’ve hung on to.. I’ve learned the path I thought I wanted doesn’t usually work out but is usually a great path also. I now have three wonderful adopted kids and can’t imagine not having them but all those years of yearning, shots, and dr visits have shaped me for the better and hopefully allowed me to have more sympathy an empathy for others.

  13. Donna G. Avatar

    Bless you! I had five miscarriages, but I do have five children. Regardless of what causes the loss of a child and the number you have, it hurts. It hurts physically, mentally, and emotionally. My number was 6. I was positive I was supposed to have 6 kids. We even considered two different adoptions that didn’t get very far. Allow yourself to grieve, and love that place in your heart where you’ll always hold those children. XO!

  14. jen s Avatar
    jen s

    What an amazing story – so brave & honest. I can’t imagine going through all of this – try to stay in a place of joy & contentment, but don’t deny yourself the acknowledgement of the shift.

  15. Kristin wyowoman Avatar

    Hugs Jenn. I relate to this, too- You are so right on.

  16. Denise Avatar
    Denise

    Thanks for sharing your story Jenn. I haven’t personally experienced infertility, but I have experienced not being able to have more (because of health issues). I know all too well the sadness of realizing you didn’t get to really savor those last baby moments. Stay strong and know you’re not alone. And those three sweet girls are so lucky to have a great mama like you! ((HUGS))

  17. creole wisdom Avatar

    Oh Jenn. This is so hard, but so beautiful. Sometimes things can be both? Your three girls are lovely and beautiful. You are one great mom.
    “But we all have different visions for our lives, and I had to give myself permission to mourn the loss of this particular dream.”
    This really resonated with me. Even if I’ve never been in your shoes, I can understand the different versions of life thing. We all have to mourn for what hasn’t happened.
    It’s a beautiful place to be: acceptance. It may not be easy, but it’s a good place to be.
    ((hugs)) to you.

  18. Nancee Avatar
    Nancee

    I’ve watched one of my best friends struggle with fertility issues and miscarriages for years. It breaks my heart for you and her. Wishing you light, love and blessings.

  19. Shelby Avatar

    Thank you for sharing your story. I could feel how you feel through what you wrote, and I think so many women who’ve waited so desperately for something they want so very much will really understand what you’re feeling. Seven and a half years ago, these feelings would have been straight from my heart and te hardest part was feeling that no one truly understood.
    Thank you again for sharing 🙂

  20. Sara Avatar
    Sara

    Thanks for sharing your story. I’ve been reading your blog for a long time and I love reading about your beautiful girls. It’s ok to grieve for your loss. They are lucky to have you as a mother! Wishing you all the best.

  21. NC Avatar
    NC

    What a beautifully written story. I’m glad you are finding peace with your situation and taking comfort in your girls. And such a beautiful set of pictures at the end of the post. Thanks for sharing.

  22. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Aw, Jenn. I am so sorry and know exactly what you are going through. We mourned the “loss” of a third baby not too long ago and have discovered that two is our lucky number. hugs I’m glad you gave yourself permission to grieve. Give those gorgeous girls a hug.

  23. Mell Avatar
    Mell

    I’m just at the beginning of trying for our first child. After 2 years with no luck naturally trying to conceive, my life is now full of doctors visits and appointments and plans.
    I desperately want my 1st child so I can feel your pain at wanting number 4 if that is what your heart was set on.
    I wish you all the luck and hope that maybe a miracle will happen for a surprise natural conception.
    Please pray for us as we start this new, scary, unknown IVF journey
    Thank you

  24. Tiffany Avatar
    Tiffany

    Having never dealt with infertility personally, I can only imagine the physical and emotional toll it takes on a person. Thank you for sharing your story, I was holding back tears by the end of it.
    P.S. So glad you’re back. I always enjoy reading your words and seeing your photos. 🙂

  25. Molly Avatar

    Jenn, I don’t know what to say, but I wanted to say something. I have sure grown to love you and your sweet girls thru this blog. You are an amazing person and you inspire me to be a better mom. I wish I could give you hug and thank you for letting us into your life here. I am sending prayers of love and comfort for you and your family.

  26. Jessy Madsen Avatar

    Jenn,
    I’m friends with Lindsey (Sullivan) Rutter and found your blog through hers years ago and have been blog-stalking since I first read of your IVF experience with Claire. I was simultaneously undergoing IVF at the time (which resulted in the birth of my first child, Will, who turned 5 in February), so I felt very drawn to you and our similar experiences (plus, I live in New York, too, though we’re upstate). I’ve done IVF 7 times now (can you believe??) the fifth time resulting in my little girl who is now 21 months (and she’s a Lucy, too–it’s always been my favorite girl name). In January and March we went through it again, with no luck. So, this post really struck a chord. I feel exactly as you do, though I am sure I could not have put it so eloquently. I’m so grateful for what I have, while still mourning the loss of my own vision. And trying to decide if we should find acceptance or try again. Our insurance covers one more cycle and my problem is low ovarian reserve (I only get a few eggs each retrieval–like 5 to 6 so it’s a numbers game for me).
    Anyway, just wanted to thank you for your words, wish you luck and tell you what a beautiful family you have. Three is a good place to be:)
    P.S. You’re an amazing photographer. I’m so jealous of your skills!

  27. Terri G. Avatar
    Terri G.

    I’m so sorry for what you’ve been through. I can’t imagine the emotional toll. Prayers for comfort and strength as you move forward.

  28. shannon b Avatar

    Jennifer, I feel like you are telling a story about me . . . . me about 5 years ago. Four was also my magic number. We tried for baby number 4 and it just. never. happened. It was hard because I never had trouble getting pregnant with the other 3! But now nothing. We didn’t do anything “heroic” because I thought, hey, we have 3 kids we should be content/thankful for what we do have. But . . .
    It was hard for me to accept the fact that we would have “just 3 kids”. I had this weird idea in my head that families with 3 kids just looked sad. I know, weird. Four was the magic number! Sometimes I wondered that we didn’t try “hard enough”, and every month for years later I secretly hoped for a surprise pregnancy. Like, up until last year even.
    I, too, felt robbed of all the “lasts”. I didn’t know that Anna would be my last. We had bought a new house while we were in the middle of trying to get pregnant, and it had an extra bedroom that I planned would be the nursery. All of the baby clothes, crib, and gear sat in that room, unused, for one year. Eventually, I realized that it was time to give away all the baby stuff. That was HARD. And for years my oldest would constantly ask when we were going to have another baby. So I totally understand what you have been feeling.
    But I’ve gotten to a place where I am ok. I like where our family is at. I like the freedom that we have to do activities and outings and vacations. We are a family of 5.
    Thank you for sharing your story. I know it is hard to do. I’m sorry for all the heartache you’ve had to endure this year. It does get better. Just look at your girls and love them for the gift that they are! I always try to think, maybe our family of 5 will be able to go on adventures and do things that wouldn’t have been possible if we were 6. You just never know the reasons why life turns out the way it does.
    Hugs.

  29. Jennifer Winder Avatar

    Such a sweet post. Heartbreaking but still sweet. Your desires are so pure. Infertility is not my trial. I can not relate, but my heart goes out to you. I cried during this post because I know the love that goes into raising children and the heart ache and the trials and the complete and utter joy at the end of the day. When someone as good as you struggles, I feel compassion and empathy for you. Thank you for sharing your heart and with us.

  30. MaryRuth Avatar

    Thank you for sharing this… I unfortunately know the pain of several failed IVF’s… and the begging and pleading and hoping “for just one more” baby… I appreciate you sharing… Infertility is a crappy, lonely experience… and while you wish others weren’t going through it… its nice to know you’re not alone.
    I wish you and your family all the best.
    xoxoxo
    MaryRuth

  31. Leanne Avatar
    Leanne

    I have followed and loved your blog for several years and want to thank you for sharing this story. I, too, have struggled with infertility and have had to cope with the loss of a dream. I had always envisioned having four kids each two years apart, but it’s been a very long and difficult journey both physically and emotionally to get the two kids I have now (a boy and a girl 4 1/2 years apart). You have beautiful girls, and you seem like an amazing mom. I wish you nothing but the best!

Leave a Reply to ellen pattonCancel reply

Discover more from Jennifer Woodbury

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading